Has anyone played a campaign using noob's 'Panzer Campaign' combo?

Nathangun

FGM Major General
FGM MEMBER
As the title suggest. I pondering if I should purchase Panzer campaigns and wondering if it's worth while paying out the $40 for a game I might rarely play.
I only came across a AAR of such a campaign in the BF forums last night where Panzer Campaigns was used as the operational layer, it looked quite good, it was set in Sicily.
Had anyone given this ago or would like to?
 
Hi,

sorry, I managed to overlook this. :)

A bit of history: CMPzC was started by he guy that goes by 'noob' on the BFC forum. He put a lot of work in it but is also a control freak. IIRC we started to campaign three times and every time he found some rule glitches and started it over.
At this point Fizou, Kuderian, another guy and myself split off and started a campaign in Sicily with the rules we had and solved things on the fly. That went without problems.

I can not say much about the workload involved to transfer unit data between CM and PzC since I only played the CM side. AFAIK most problems come from mapping unit sizes and getting the headcount right. Then you have to make a map of course.
Setting up the scenario would either require a referee or some trust not to look into the others setup. We went with the latter.

Problems:
- retreats: in CM it's easy to leave the map without losses. So you could run away for ever without punishment. So we put in some rules that you take a morale hit if you leave too early.
- when not to play CM: some setups are too unbalanced to be fun but others are. Discerning those is difficult.
- realism vs playability: this is an ever ongoing debate and is a matter of personal preference. It should be clear from the start to which camp you belong to avoid conflicts later.
 
@poesel71 :The campaign you talking about is the Route to Ribera campaign right? I just wanted to say I am following this since it began and I am having a blast just reading it. Looks really interesting. And you are right about noob. He is a control freak. I got my share of this also as I was once involved for a short time in one of his campaign. But dropped out even before it really began as he constantly changed rules and he didn`t know exactly what he really wants. I was a good descision as the "campaign" lasted for just 2 turns and the he forced everybody to stop playing it.
 
@poesel71 :The campaign you talking about is the Route to Ribera campaign right? I just wanted to say I am following this since it began and I am having a blast just reading it.

I came across that AAR last week and I'm working my way through it and have to say I'm impressed the way it's done.
I thought it's worth giving ago and I now have a copy of the Panzer Campaigns Market Garden game.

I'm currently learning how to play the game. Once myself and Bootie can agree on a scenario and a balanced OOB for the scenario.
I'll be willing to do all the 'donkey work'. Like doing up the entire OOB's in CM and making maps. I'm sure there will be maps already in CMMG.

@Bootie I'm thinking of "Hells Highway B' but I'm open to other suggestions.
 
Back
Top Bottom